The Presumption of Innocence vs The Presumption of Guilt; The Nigerian Bail Story.

In Nigeria, every person (including suspects and defendants/accused persons) is assumed to be innocent until a court declares a person guilty. This is a constitutional right that should not be violated by any person (including law enforcement agencies, institutions, leaders and government). However, the reverse is the case, with overzealous law enforcement agencies, going in the circles of; abuse, arrest, abuse, detain and abuse again before taking the suspect to court (if the suspect is fortunate to be arraigned). In Nigeria, “Bail” is mostly seen in law books and movies, since many suspects are detained without bail for weeks in all parts of Nigeria and lawyers get beaten up for seeking bail for clients. This work reveals the quickest means of obtaining bail after 24 hours of arrest in any part of Nigeria.

There is a big gap between criminal law and human rights as contained in our law books and as applied in reality. There are three groups of law enforcement agents in Nigeria; the first group understands the law and applies it thoroughly, the second group understands the law but will not apply it due to corruption, nepotism and fear while the third group does not understand the law and does not care. Unfortunately, the last group seems to be dominating followed by the second group, as such human rights suppressed. Among the concerned human rights are; right to life, right to dignity of human person, right to personal liberty, right to fair hearing and right to freedom of movement.


The essence of bail is to enable a suspect to go home and about his affairs while ensuring the suspect will at a later date, appear in a given place (like the office of a law enforcement agency or in court for investigation or to answer to his case). Bail is not a privilege or favour done to a suspect rather a right of a suspect. Remember that a suspect is not guilty so he/she should not suffer or be treated as if he is guilty. Consequently, a suspect that is detained for an offence not punishable with death (non-capital offences) is entitled to bail within 24 hours of being arrested.

The police (any law enforcement agency) time for detaining a suspect arrested for an offence that is not to be punished with death (non-capital offences) is 24 hours. Time starts counting from the moment a person is arrested, ceased or appears to answers an invitation of a law enforcement agency (whatever the language/term, so far as a person is no longer free). So, once a suspect is arrested, the law enforcement agency must ensure that its further investigation, bio-data capturing, granting of bail and seeking for advice, approval and any indoor management/protocol is completed within 24 hours. Where a suspect is detained beyond 24 hours for an offence that is not punishable with death, the suspect can be granted bail by a court having jurisdiction over the offence.

In Nigeria, a detained person may not be allowed to approach a court to seek his own bail or to even access a lawyer of his/her choice, by overzealous law enforcement agents working on ignorance or corruption. Hence, where a suspect is not granted bail by a law enforcement agency within 24 hours over a non-capital offence, any person can go to court and institute a case against the concerned law enforcement agency (and its agents) on behalf of the suspect. The court will order the suspect to be produced (brought to) court and inquire into the circumstances of the detention. Where the court desires, the court will grant bail to the suspect. The required application for bail in court, can be written or oral, even if the court is a superior court (High Court/Federal High Court/National Industrial Court).

It is better to engage a lawyer to assist with bail application in court. Bail is a right and not a favour. Bail is free because it is a constitutional and fundamental human right, provided freely by the Constitution of Nigeria. Report any law enforcement agent, court staff, magistrate, judge or legal practitioner that request for money/gift in order to grant bail. However, a legal practitioner is entitled to charge for his legal services but no to charge any fee to be paid as bribe or gift for bail.

My authorities are:

1. Sections 32, 161, 162, 163, 164, 494 and 495 of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act 2015 and its equivalent in states across Nigeria.
2. Sections 34, 35, 36, 230, 237, 249, 255, 260, 265, 318 and 319 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999.
3. Judgment of the Supreme Court of Nigeria (on the nature and effect of Bail) in the case of SULEMAN & ANOR v. COP PLATEAU STATE (2008) LPELR-3126(SC)
4. Judgement of the Supreme Court of Nigeria (on bail) in the case of UGWU v. STATE (2020) LPELR-49375(SC)
5. Judgement of the Court of Appeal (that every person is presumed innocent) in the case of ALAYA v. STATE (2007) LPELR-8841(CA) citing Eyu v. The State (1988) 2 NWLR (Pt.78) 602 at 610, Abiola v. FR.N. (1995) 7 NWLR (Pt.405) 1 at 155
6. Judgment of the Court of Appeal (on whether bail can be granted in non-capital offences) in the case of OGEDE v. FRN (2018) LPELR-46816(CA)
7. Judgment of the Court of Appeal (on whether bail can be granted in capital offences) in the case of OGEDE v. FRN (2018) LPELR-46816(CA)
8. Judgment of the Court of Appeal (that oral bail application can be made in any court, including courts of record) in the case of Chief Alhaji Moshood Kashimawo Abiola V. Federal Republic of Nigeria (1995) NWRL PART 370 P.155.
9. James Ezeh, “Nigerian Lawyer Hospitalised after Police Assault, NBA Demands Justice” (Premuim Times, 13 October 2019) 1 September 2020.

© thenigerianlawyer.com
7/10/2020

HRCRC Facilitates the Release of over 20 inmates of Abakaliki and Afikpo Prisons in Goal Delivery by CJ of Ebonyi State

Every person charged for committing an offence is entitled to be arraigned and tried before a competent court of law within 48 hours. However, certain alleged offenders have been remanded in prison for over two years without trial.

The Chief judge in his magnanimity, backed up by statutory provisions, discharged alleged offenders awaiting trial in a goal delivery exercise. Over 50 persons awaiting trial were discharged

HRCRC is happy to be part of this exercised, facilitating the release of a number of alleged offenders, spare headed by the lawyers in the department of Access to Justice.

Rights of the Suspect and Accused

Recently, a young man came to our office alongside his old father. They came to lodge a complaint. About a month earlier, they said, they got a call from an unidentified female informing them that their son was picked up by the DSS from one of the streets in Abakaliki. They quickly got to town and went to inquire at the DSS state’s command and were denied acc

DSS men

ess to the facilities. They requested to know whether their son was being held at the facility and on what ground he was held. Their request was ignored, and they were asked to leave the premises. At another time, they contracted a lawyer whom they took there for intervention, we were told. The lawyer was equally turned away without seeing the detainee except that, he was told, the boy was in their custody.

It took our intervention to later find out that the boy was charged to high court for ‘kidnaping’ and was remanded in Abakaliki Prison. All the time the boy was held in their custody, he was denied access to his relatives and to legal representation.
______________________________________________

One striking feature of democracy is the rule of law. Where due process is blatantly ignored or disregarded, democracy suffers a great blow, and so does human rights. The case represented above is very common, not only with the security agency mentioned, but with many others, including the police force. It is as if, for many security agents, there are no rules guiding the procedure of arrests and detention, and that once an individual is a suspect in an offence or crime, the individual seizes to have human rights. This practice and the ideology that informs it violate international norms and practices regarding arrest, detention and trial procedures as can be found in Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UNDHR), International Convention on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CAT) and Body of Principles for the Protection of All Persons under Any Form of Detention or Imprisonment. It equally negates Nigeria’s laws, including the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (1999 as amended), Criminal Procedure Act, Criminal Procedure Code and the most recent act which merged the last two, Administration of Criminal Justice Act (ACJA, 2015). With regard to arrest and detention, there are key human rights issues that must be safeguarded as far as best international principles and practice are concerned. They include:

Right to liberty and security of person and to freedom of movement (ICCPR, 9[1], Constitution, 35[1])
Prohibition of arbitrary arrest (UDHR, 9)
Right to be informed of reasons at time of arrest and of any charges (Constitution, 36[6][a], 35[2], ACJA, 6)
Right to be brought promptly before a judge (UDHR, 10)
Right to trial within reasonable time, or release (Constitution, 36[1], ACJA)
Right to prompt access to a lawyer (Constitution, 36[6][C])
Right not to confess or testify against oneself (of silence) (ACJA, Constitution, 35[2])
Right to an interpreter when necessary (ACJA, Constitution, 36 [6][e])
Right to prompt notification of family (ACJA,
Right to presumption of innocence until proven guilty (UDHR, article 11, ICCPR 14[2], Constitution 36[5])
Right to humane treatment as a detainee (ACJA, 8)
Because of the requirement to safeguard these rights, security operatives are supposed to be guided by four principles – LEGALITY, NECESSITY, PROPORTIONALITY and ACCOUNTABILITY – whenever they carry out arrest and detention of persons suspected or accused of committing an offence/crime.

By legal consideration, they are to ascertain in the particularities of a case whether an arrest with/without a warrant is needed. It also requires the security agent to determine whether a mere invitation or arrest for detention is needed in a particular case. This is because certain civil cases do not require the involvement of police carrying out arrest. In McLaren v. Jennings, the Court of Appeal held in 2003 that it was unlawful for the police to arrest and detain the appellant with regard to the collection of a debt (a civil matter) which could be determined in courts or through the use of ADRs. Unfortunately, in practice, some security agents are often used to settle scores by individuals who consider themselves ‘connected’ to their power (soft or hard).

By necessity, issues of timing, and place of arrest are to be considered. Does it require doing it in such a manner to cause public knowledge which may cause harm to the reputation of the suspect (remember, a suspect is not a convict) or could it be done in some quite place and time.

Proportionality calls for prudency with regards to the use of force during an arrest (ACJA now provides that no unnecessary restraint such as handcuff is required).

Accountability requires that arrested persons should be brought before a court of competent authority who must decide the validity of the arrest and whether further detention is necessary or not. It also places a burden on the security agents to ensure relatives of detainees are promptly informed.

Thus, if you examine the particular case shown in the first paragraph critically, one can detect that there were serious violations of the fundamental rights of the suspect. He was denied access to a lawyer and his relatives were shut out from him. Also, if we were to go by the provision of the ACJA which now requires that detention without appearance before a judge/magistrate going beyond 48hrs at most is unnecessary, we can see how the young man’s rights to ‘be brought promptly before a judge’ was violated. Any action against the agency in question has to take these factors into consideration. More importantly, our interest here is to demonstrates to readers that even a suspect does have fundamental rights that need not be compromised.

Shalom!

Contributors: C. O. Ikegbunam Esq.
C. A. Nwankwo Esq.
D. A. Okoliko

Disclaimer:
This is a free educational material and not a source of legal advice. If you need any, please consult your lawyer.